You cannot copy content of this website, your IP is being recorded
Open MRI vs. Closed MRI Q&A

Open MRI vs. Closed MRI Q&A

Open MRIs present several advantages over closed MRIs, primarily in terms of patient comfort and accessibility. They are designed to be quieter and less enclosed, making them more suitable for patients prone to claustrophobia or anxiety. Talked to meet Dr. Eric Feldmann, MD for an MRI at Mosaic Diagnostic Imaging. For more information contact us today or book an appointment online. We are conveniently located at 165 N Village Ave # 116, Rockville Centre, NY, 11570.

Open MRI vs. Closed MRI Near Me in Rockville Centre, NY
Open MRI vs. Closed MRI Near Me in Rockville Centre, NY

Table of Contents:

What are MRI machines?
What Is a Closed MRI?
What are the pros and cons of open MRI?
What are the pros and cons of closed MRI?

What are MRI machines?


Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) machines are non-invasive imaging technology capable of providing detailed anatomical images. This non-invasive and painless scan is capable of capturing detailed images of various structures and organs within the body, functioning effectively in almost any area and covering large sections quickly.

Its ability to diagnose a wide range of abnormalities, diseases, and injuries, from cancerous tumors to conditions affecting the heart, spinal cord, brain, and eyes, makes it a valuable diagnostic tool. Unlike other testing methods, MRI can identify many conditions in their earliest stages, leading to swift and accurate diagnoses.

This early detection is crucial as it can significantly improve health outcomes and potentially avoid the need for more expensive treatments later if the condition worsens.

MRI’s utility extends beyond initial diagnosis, it’s also used to monitor how well treatments for various conditions are working, allowing for adjustments based on detected changes.

This tailored approach to treatment, based on MRI findings, can lead to better long-term health outcomes for patients. Another significant advantage of MRI is that it involves no radiation exposure, making it a safe option, particularly for those vulnerable to the effects of radiation.

What Is a Closed MRI?


A closed MRI, the longest-standing type of MRI technology, functions by encompassing the patient within a capsule-like, magnetized space. During the scan, radio waves are sent to the body and the signals that return are converted by computers into highly detailed images.

This process allows for a non-invasive and accurate view of an individual’s internal functioning, aiding doctors in making precise diagnoses and treatment plans.

The space where the patient lies during a closed MRI is typically long and narrow, differentiating it from an open MRI.

What are the pros and cons of open MRI?


Open MRIs present several advantages over closed MRIs, primarily in terms of patient comfort and accessibility. They are designed to be quieter and less enclosed, making them more suitable for patients prone to claustrophobia or anxiety.

This feature also makes open MRIs more child-friendly and accommodating for larger patients. Open MRI systems can be operated in various ways to facilitate the diagnosis of specific conditions, such as tilting the patient into an upright position for better assessment of back pain and spinal injuries.

Open MRIs, being a newer form of MRI technology, can offer cost savings in many cases due to requiring less engineering manpower for service and installation.

They use magnets both above and below the patient and are open on all four sides, reducing the risk of claustrophobia and panic attacks. This open design also makes them beneficial for individuals with mobility issues, providing a more comfortable and smoother experience for those who are physically disabled.

However, open MRIs have some limitations, primarily in image resolution. The images produced by open MRIs can sometimes be of lower resolution in certain areas of the body. Therefore, the decision between an open and closed MRI will be dictated by healthcare providers based on each patient’s specific needs.

What are the pros and cons of closed MRI?


The primary advantage of a closed MRI is its ability to produce highly detailed images, enabling the diagnosis of a wide array of medical conditions, including those in their early stages.

This capability is due to the design and function of the closed MRI, which allows for a high degree of precision in imaging. The closed structure of the MRI machine can produce images not achievable by other scanning methods, making it indispensable in certain diagnostic situations.

However, the closed MRI comes with several drawbacks. The confined space of the capsule-like machine can induce feelings of claustrophobia in patients. The requirement for patients to remain entirely still during the scan, which can take several minutes, can add to the discomfort.

Additionally, the narrow passage of the machine may not accommodate obese or larger patients. The noise generated by closed MRI systems is another factor that can cause excess anxiety, particularly for claustrophobic individuals. These cons of closed MRI necessitate careful consideration by healthcare providers and patients, especially those with anxiety or claustrophobia when choosing the most appropriate imaging method.

For patients who are particularly anxious about undergoing a closed MRI, alternatives like anti-anxiety medication or relaxation techniques can be discussed with their doctor.

Additionally, bringing a relative or friend for support can be helpful, especially if a sedative is taken, in which case the patient will need someone to drive them home.

For more information contact Mosaic Diagnostic Imaging. We serve patients from Rockville Centre NY, Lakeview NY, Baldwin NY, Lynbrook NY, Hempstead NY, West Hempstead NY, Oceanside NY, and the surrounding areas. Visit us online today for directions to our leading clinic.